As the Christmas season is upon us, and goodwill is all around, I was gladdened that one of my like-minded friends was thoughtful enough to forward me a delightful poem that was apparently in the news some time ago:
http://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Politics/documents/2006/11/06/1106poem.pdf
As you can see, it really is hysterical. He was sent it by a lovely lady whom I shall merely refer to as Lisa. I don’t think it’s right to bandy a woman’s name about. Not that I’m implying she’s bandy, of course. I wrote to her thusly:
Dear Lisa,
I was forwarded the ditty on immigration and I must say it really brightened my day.
I was a little concerned about some of this fine work, however. I notice that many of the terms used (“welfare”, “yard”, “truck” “aliens” etc.) seem to be American in origin, leading me to believe that the poem was written by an American. I do hope we’re not celebrating the work of a foreigner here. Okay, they may look the same as us but nevertheless, they’re still invaders to these shores. Especially near Harrods.
Also, I note that you say the country is getting full. I’m sure I read somewhere that we’re the 48th most populous country in the world, Countries more densely populated than us include Grenada, Samao and Barbados, which never really struck me as concreted high-rise hellholes, to be honest. Still, you know best. I’m assuming.
I showed the poem to my wife and I have to say she was less impressed than I. She’s a rather strident woman, the kind of person who won’t even allow me to watch re-runs of “Love Thy Neighbour” in peace. She was really picky about your poem, insisting on using facts and research rather than common sense. Just listen to some of the nonsense she wrote:
“The poem states that immigrants ‘love breeding’ but there has been little change in the under-20 population since 1990 (http://www.statistics.gov.uk/cci/nugget.asp?id=716). The national statistic centre also said this:
“In Great Britain, there has been an increase in the proportion of dependent children living in lone parent families with 23 per cent of dependent children living in a lone parent family in 2001 compared with 18 per cent in 1991. Couple families were relatively most frequent among Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi headed households.”
In other words, the greatest population increase from one-parent families has come from traditionally non-ethnic households.
As for the idea that benefit-claiming is all immigrants do, this is what the National Statistic Centre found:
The proportion of working-age people living in workless households was lowest for the Indian ethnic group, at 6.8 per cent; while 11.0 per cent of those in the white ethnic group lived in a workless household.
So ‘welfare scroungers’ are more likely to be white than Indian.”
To be honest, my wife went on in this vein for some time. I switched off after a while. Jack Smethurst had just dressed up as a Zulu to scare his neighbour. He does make me laugh.
It’s good to see a strong Christian message being circulated at this time of year. What would a Muslim know about the Christian concept of charity? Apart from Zakat, one of the five pillars of the Muslim faith, obviously.
There are literally dozens of respected organisations that might accuse you of spreading racial hatred, but I’m not one of them. And if you have somebody as sensible as me on your side, you know you can’t be wrong, eh?
Merry Christmas. Peace on you all.
UPDATE:
Well Lisa really is a very keen correspondent! A reply the very same day!
Well Hello Nick & Unnamed Wife,
So the Illegal Immigrant Poem seems to doing the rounds with my name attached now
...I don't suppose you will want to share who gave you my email details? Don't bother... I think it is obvious... it must be the same person that has emailed me at least 5 times this morning (I have not responded to her at all) and emailed all my contacts without my permission at least twice and she has now threatened us all with the following...
I shall forward ANY literature (including the poem) and senders details to the University authorities and to Searchlight – an anti-racist organisation that you may find interesting.
Perhaps she wants me to reply to you instead?
You seem to be very interested in statistics... do you know what Disraeli said about Lies, Damned Lies and Statistics?
With so many illegal immigrants here how can a argument based on numbers possibly stand up to scrutiny?
My last word on the subject was as follows...
I think you are missing the point, I have repeatedly said that I and most English people are tolerant towards immigrants in real need... like your Rwandan friend or my Syrian friends who have had their families brutally murdered and who are distressed at the fact that they cannot stay in their beloved homeland
... it is the thousands of spongers who we question have the right to our council houses, our benefits, our land... especially those who are here planning to make this a muslim country by force and those here illegally who are not included in the statistics you quote... the BBC have recently showed how easy it is to get a false passport and gain entry and get all the benefits that are fast running out... !
My grandparents who fought for our freedom and paid into the NHS & Welfare Benefit system for their children and their children's children are turning in their graves!
Let's make a New Years Resolution for 2007 to wake up and call a halt to this madness.
Let me take this opportunity to wish you a Happy & Prosperous New Year for 2007.
Seasons Greetings!
Lisa ______
There followed some very interesting anecdotes, which I have edited, of people being shoved on the bus by a foreigner, an old soldier who doesn’t like seeing so many variations of skin colour on the street. Stuff like that. Most heartwarming. I replied thusly:
Dear Lisa,
Thanks for the quick reply – our type needs to stick together, don’t you feel?
Not sure if your email has been ‘doing the rounds’ (a term once used in relation to my daughter and one I’m not terribly keen on) but a like-minded friend certainly thought I’d enjoy it, yes. He attached your name to the email, I think, because your name was on it and you’d sent it. Odd behaviour, I know, but there you are.
This whole email business is a bit fraught though, don’t you think? The problem is, I feel, that people will assume that if you express very strong and, to some muddle-headed Trotskyists, outdated views in an email, that you can assume this is how you actually view things. Nonsense.
Not sure about this person who has been emailing you all the time – I can only assume her housework is done for the day. I tend not to let my wife near the computer until early evening. At least that gives me the chance to ensure the websites my nephew has been visiting don’t pop up (a rather apt term, I feel) while she’s studying for her book club. But to threaten you in that manner does seem rather harsh. Regardless of what the law, civil liberties groups and employment procedure might think.
I’m happy for you to reply to me though, obviously. Nice to hear somebody talking some sense for a change. Although I should point out it’s the wife who has an interest in statistics. She seems to think facts are the way forward to understanding society. I know, I know. Madness. I agree with Disraeli too, despite his immigrant background.
You’re right, of course, that my wife cannot use facts to support an argument – how ridiculous. We do not know how many illegal immigrants are in this country, although the Home Office seems to think it does and puts the figure at roughly 430,000. Or put another way, Sheffield. Frightening though, eh? A huge, sprawling metropolis the sheer scale of Sheffield made up of low-paid folk with virtually no access to support services? Makes the skin crawl.
Glad to hear you’re tolerant toward immigrants. I tolerate next door playing the trumpet at 8am, I tolerate my hayfever during the summer and it’s good to see you tolerate the influx of people into this country since the Romans in the same manner. It’s the spongers we need to look out for. The people who do little jobs on the side while their husband works. Things like that. Although with no figures on what proportion of fraud is caused by illegal immigrants available, we’re going to have to rely on anecdotes, which is where I usually form my opinions (unlike my fact-obsessed wife).
And it’s always best to assume that absolute worst, isn’t it? I’d rather ten needy people and one scrounger starved to death than ten needy people get benefits along with one scrounger, wouldn’t you?
So yes, let’s call a halt to the madness. We should close the borders. None shall enter. We should follow the example of two countries with the lowest rates of immigrants in the world – The Phillipines and Guyana. Sounds great, doesn’t it? Imagine our country sharing their quality of life? All that lovely hot weather, for a start.
Seasonal greetings.
Yours etc.